Chicken Pot Pie Recipe for Two - About a Mom (2024)

FAQs

Can you cook two chicken pot pies at once? ›

Yes, baking two pies at once is fine, as long as the recipes for both pies specify the same oven temperature. If you are baking them on the same oven shelf, make sure that there's plenty of space around each pie, and that they are not too close to each other or to the oven walls.

Stir a tablespoon of cornstarch into 2 tablespoons of cold water and add it to your filling mixture to thicken it.

A watery potpie may be the result of not cooking the filling for long enough or adding too much liquid to the filling. Another possible reason for the pie being watery is if you add watery vegetables like spinach or green beans to the filling rather than potatoes or carrots, which soak up liquid.

Vegetables: A top-of-the-line potpie is filled with tender, colorful veggies. This recipe uses potatoes, carrots, frozen peas and corn. Cream sauce: The creamy sauce starts with a roux, which is a combination of butter and flour that thickens the sauce.

USE AN AVERAGE TEMPERATURE

You can bake several dishes at once by setting your oven to the average temperature called for across recipes. If, for instance, one dish requires a temperature of 350℉ and another needs to bake at 400℉, set the temperature to 375℉ and keep a close eye on food as it cooks.

We suggest freezing your chicken pot pie filling unbaked. You can pre-cook it and then freeze and then re-bake to reheat, but if you do that, you may want to under-bake your pie crust just a little before you freeze.

The sauce in chicken pot pie is typically a gravy. I use a seasoned white gravy made from scratch with flavor-building ingredients, chicken broth, and half-and-half.

I only gave my pot pie a top crust, because I feel like the bottom crust always gets soggy. If you do want to add a bottom crust, I suggest blind baking it. What does blind baking mean? It's when you bake your pie crust without a filling in order to crisp it up.

Unfortunately, the filling relies on flour for thickening. However, you can substitute it to make it truly gluten free a few ways. You can dissolve cornstarch in the COLD milk before pouring it into the skillet. You can use a one-for-one gluten free flour substitution, or you can use arrowroot!

In the South, some folks make a distinction between chicken pie and chicken pot pie. Chicken pies, also known as “chicken and pastry,” are the savory versions of fruit pies or cobblers, made with homemade crust and no, or very few, vegetables. Chicken pot pies typically include vegetables and have a top crust only.

Does chicken pot pie thicken as it cools? ›

As the filling cools it will thicken, and if you slice the pie before it cools to room temperature, it won't thicken no matter how long you wait. This is also true of pies with custard fillings. They need to have that elusive jiggly center when you take them out of the oven.

That being said, if you want your pot pie soup thicker, you could add more flour during that step, or you can stir in a cornstarch slurry at the end.

Chicken pot pie is an all-American comfort food. The most iconic version of it originated in Lancaster, in Pennsylvania Dutch country, but was brought to the United States by European settlers and had its roots in English dishes made from leftovers.

If one dish calls for a roasting temp of 325 degrees F (165 degrees C) and another calls for 375 degrees F (190 degrees C), you can meet in the middle and cook both at 350 degrees F (175 degrees C). Most ovens are usually off by about 25 degrees, so both should be fine.

Can you cook 2 or more dishes in the oven at once? Yes. Most people fret when it comes to cooking two dishes at once, but it's your oven's job to keep the internal temperature set to what you selected. It may have to work a little harder when two or more cold dishes are inserted but trust that it will do its job.

We enjoy pot pies and when we are in a hurry sometimes put two in the microwave at the same time. Usually it takes 7-8 minutes per pie. If two are in the oven at the same time (same size too) I multiply the time times 1.5. Generally it works out well.

As long as you have enough space between your shelves there's no problem cooking chicken pieces on 2 layers. Some tips: Make sure you have enough space around the trays as well so air can circulate, if you don't you'll get uneven cooking.